Chess openings for Black
By Chessvia · Updated Nov 17, 2026
In Lichess games from September 2026 at ratings 1000 to 1399, the Sicilian, French and Caro-Kann score best for Black against 1.e4 among the five defenses here. Among the four
1.d4 lines, the King's Indian scores best, counting games that began
1.d4
Nf6
2.c4
g6, some of which became a Grünfeld. The Caro-Kann and the Slav share ...c6 and ...d5 pawns, so they make a starter pair if White plays 2.c4.
For players rated about 800 to 1700 choosing a defense to learn as Black. The opening results are drawn from five rating bands covering 61.1 million Lichess games played in September 2026, and each board steps through the first moves. The bands start at 1000 to 1199, so there is no sample for players rated 800 to 999.
Chess openings for Black at a glance
Black answers 1.e4 and 1.d4 with one defense each. The scores below count Lichess games where both players are rated 1000 to 1399 (14,605,077 games). Pick by the plan you want to play as much as by the numbers.
- Against 1.e4: the Sicilian (50.5%), French (50.4%) and Caro-Kann (50.4%) score best for Black at 1000 to 1199, ahead of the Scandinavian (48.5%) and 1...e5 (47.3%). See the five defenses
- Against 1.d4: of the four lines here, the King's Indian line scores 50.3% at 1200 to 1399, ahead of the Dutch (47.4%), the Slav (47.1%) and the Queen's Gambit Declined (46.4%). See the four defenses
- Beginners: the Caro-Kann against 1.e4 and the Slav against 1.d4 share the ...c6 and ...d5 pawn structure. Chess openings for Black beginners
- Aggressive: the Sicilian's ...c5 pressure on d4, the King's Indian's ...f5 break and the Dutch's early ...f5 are three sharp plans to try. Aggressive defenses for Black
Chess openings for Black against 1.e4
Five defenses meet 1.e4. Each card has a board you can step through, the first moves, a plan to play, and how Black scores with it at 1200 to 1399 and in the bands either side.
After 1...e5
Open Game (1...e5)
1.e4 e5 · you meet 1.e4
Matches White's pawn move and fights for the center directly.
Good if you want to bring your pieces out fast and castle early. The plan: ...Nc6 and ...Nf6, castle, then break with ...d5. You will meet the Italian Game, Ruy Lopez and Scotch Game, so set aside time for their main lines.
White 51.1%Draws 3.3%Black 45.7%Results at 1200 to 1399, 2,780,978 games. Black's score (wins plus half the draws) is 47.3% here, 47.3% at 1000 to 1199, 47.5% at 1400 to 1599 and 47.6% at 1600 to 1999.
After 1...c5
Saved engine line (Stockfish 16, depth 16) after the opening moves.
Sicilian Defense
1.e4 c5 · you meet 1.e4
Fights for d4 from the wing for an unbalanced game.
Good if you want to play for a win and will learn several set-ups. The plan: ...c5 pressures d4, you trade your c-pawn for White's d-pawn and then use the open c-file.
White 48.4%Draws 2.8%Black 48.8%Results at 1200 to 1399, 594,616 games. Black's score (wins plus half the draws) is 50.2% here, 50.5% at 1000 to 1199, 50.0% at 1400 to 1599 and 49.3% at 1600 to 1999. Engine +0.36 for White after these moves (Stockfish 16, depth 16). Learn the Sicilian Defense on a board
After 1...e6
Saved engine line (Stockfish 16, depth 16) after the opening moves.
French Defense
1.e4 e6 · you meet 1.e4
...e6 and ...d5, then ...c5 against White's pawn chain.
Good if you are happy with a locked center. The plan: ...e6 and ...d5, then hit White's pawn chain with ...c5 (at d4) and ...f6 (at e5).
White 48.3%Draws 3.0%Black 48.7%Results at 1200 to 1399, 505,966 games. Black's score (wins plus half the draws) is 50.2% here, 50.4% at 1000 to 1199, 50.2% at 1400 to 1599 and 49.7% at 1600 to 1999. Engine +0.35 for White after these moves (Stockfish 16, depth 16). Learn the French Defense on a board
After 1...c6
Saved engine line (Stockfish 16, depth 16) after the opening moves.
Caro-Kann Defense
1.e4 c6 · you meet 1.e4
Supports ...d5 with the c-pawn and keeps the light bishop free.
Good if you want a sturdy setup with few early tricks. The plan: ...c6 and ...d5, then bring the light bishop out, often to f5, before you play ...e6.
White 48.2%Draws 3.0%Black 48.8%Results at 1200 to 1399, 463,845 games. Black's score (wins plus half the draws) is 50.3% here, 50.4% at 1000 to 1199, 50.5% at 1400 to 1599 and 49.6% at 1600 to 1999. Engine +0.25 for White after these moves (Stockfish 16, depth 16). Learn the Caro-Kann Defense on a board
Chess openings for Black against 1.d4
Four defenses meet 1.d4. The Slav, the Queen's Gambit Declined and the King's Indian all assume White plays 2.c4; the Dutch (1...f5) does not.
After 2...e6
Saved engine line (Stockfish 16, depth 16) after the opening moves.
Queen's Gambit Declined
1.d4 d5 2.c4 e6 · you meet 1.d4
Meets c4 with ...e6, keeps the d5 pawn and builds a sturdy center.
Good if you want a patient, classical setup against 1.d4 d5 2.c4. The plan: ...e6, ...Nf6 and ...Be7, castle, then free your position with ...c5 or ...dxc4. Your light bishop stays shut in on c8 until then.
White 52.1%Draws 3.1%Black 44.8%Results at 1200 to 1399, 61,209 games. Black's score (wins plus half the draws) is 46.4% here, 46.9% at 1000 to 1199, 46.4% at 1400 to 1599 and 46.8% at 1600 to 1999. Engine +0.32 for White after these moves (Stockfish 16, depth 16). Learn the Queen's Gambit, with its declined lines, on a board
After 2...c6
Saved engine line (Stockfish 16, depth 16) after the opening moves.
Slav Defense
1.d4 d5 2.c4 c6 · you meet 1.d4
Supports d5 with ...c6 against the Queen's Gambit; the bishop stays free.
Good if you want the same ...c6 and ...d5 pawns you play against 1.e4. The plan: ...c6 and ...d5, then ...Nf6 and ...Bf5 before you play ...e6.
It only arises when White plays 2.c4. After 1.d4 d5 2.Bf4, play 2...c6 to keep the same pawns (see Chess openings for Black beginners).
White 51.3%Draws 3.1%Black 45.5%Results at 1200 to 1399, 40,484 games. Black's score (wins plus half the draws) is 47.1% here, 47.0% at 1000 to 1199, 47.5% at 1400 to 1599 and 46.9% at 1600 to 1999. Engine +0.39 for White after these moves (Stockfish 16, depth 16).
After 2...g6
King's Indian Defense
1.d4 Nf6 2.c4 g6 · you meet 1.d4
Fianchetto, let White take the center, then strike back.
Good if you want to counterattack and will learn plans, not just moves. The plan: ...Nf6, ...g6 and ...Bg7, castle, let White build a center, then hit it with ...e5 or ...c5. In closed centers the ...f5 pawn break starts a kingside attack.
This sample is every game that began 1.d4 Nf6 2.c4 g6. 5.4% of them at 1200 to 1399 went on 3.Nc3 d5 and became a Grünfeld, which has its own row in the score table.
White 48.3%Draws 2.8%Black 48.9%Results at 1200 to 1399, 20,849 games. Black's score (wins plus half the draws) is 50.3% here, 50.4% at 1000 to 1199, 49.8% at 1400 to 1599 and 49.5% at 1600 to 1999.
After 1...f5
Saved engine line (Stockfish 16, depth 16) after the opening moves.
Dutch Defense
1.d4 f5 · you meet 1.d4
...f5 claims e4 early, at some cost to king cover.
Good if you want kingside space and an early fight for e4. The plan: ...f5 controls e4; develop with ...Nf6, ...e6 and ...Be7, castle, then play ...d6 or ...d5 for the center.
White 51.2%Draws 2.8%Black 46.0%Results at 1200 to 1399, 32,509 games. Black's score (wins plus half the draws) is 47.4% here, 48.1% at 1000 to 1199, 48.5% at 1400 to 1599 and 48.1% at 1600 to 1999. Engine +0.61 for White after these moves (Stockfish 16, depth 16).
A score of 50% means half the available points: wins plus half the draws. Black's scores sit near or below 50% in most rows because White has the first move, so a 50% score says nothing about the position being equal. Compare a defense with the others against the same first move; a score after 1.e4 and a score after 1.d4 start from different positions. Rarer defenses with fewer games are listed near the end.
Black's openings in six numbers
- Black scores 48.2% at 1000 to 1199 and 47.7% at 2200 and up, in 5,628,817 and 5,590,869 Lichess games from September 2026 (wins plus half the draws).
- At 1000 to 1199 the Sicilian Defense scores 50.5% for Black and the Queen's Gambit Declined 46.9%, across the 9 defenses on this page.
- Among the four 1.d4 defenses here, the King's Indian line (1.d4 Nf6 2.c4 g6, which can also become a Grünfeld) scores 50.3% at 1200 to 1399 in 20,849 games, ahead of the Dutch (47.4%), the Slav (47.1%) and the Queen's Gambit Declined (46.4%).
- 1.e4 starts 64.8% of games at 1000 to 1199 and 43.4% at 2200 and up; 1.d4 starts 23.0% and 29.0%.
- The Sicilian is 8.1% of replies to 1.e4 at 1000 to 1199 and 28.4% at 2200 and up, where it is the most played reply.
- Draws are 3.1% of games at 1000 to 1199 and 6.6% at 2200 and up.
Source for all six: Lichess standard rated games, September 2026 (89,616,462 games read), counted by Chessvia. Bands count a game only when both players are inside them.
How each defense scores at your rating
Black's score is wins plus half the draws, from games where both players are in the same rating band, so 50% means half the available points. The nine card defenses are in the chart; the table below it adds two rarer ones and the bands in between. The bands start at 1000 to 1199, so there is no sample for players rated 800 to 999; read the 1000 to 1199 row as the closest one.
At 1000 to 1199 Black's score runs from 46.9% (Queen's Gambit Declined) to 50.5% (Sicilian Defense); at 2200 and up from 45.5% to 48.4%
Black's score with each defense in three rating bands. 50% means half the available points.
- 47.3% 1000 to 1199
- 47.6% 1600 to 1999
- 48.3% 2200 and up
- 50.5% 1000 to 1199
- 49.3% 1600 to 1999
- 47.8% 2200 and up
- 50.4% 1000 to 1199
- 49.7% 1600 to 1999
- 48.0% 2200 and up
- 50.4% 1000 to 1199
- 49.6% 1600 to 1999
- 47.6% 2200 and up
- 48.5% 1000 to 1199
- 49.7% 1600 to 1999
- 48.4% 2200 and up
- 46.9% 1000 to 1199
- 46.8% 1600 to 1999
- 46.8% 2200 and up
- 47.0% 1000 to 1199
- 46.9% 1600 to 1999
- 45.5% 2200 and up
- 50.4% 1000 to 1199
- 49.5% 1600 to 1999
- 47.7% 2200 and up
- 48.1% 1000 to 1199
- 48.1% 1600 to 1999
- 47.7% 2200 and up
Bars start at 44%, not zero. Dashed line: half the available points (50.0%).
Show the numbers as a table
| Defense | 1000 to 1199 | 1600 to 1999 | 2200 and up | Games, 1000 to 1199 | Games, 1600 to 1999 | Games, 2200 and up |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Open Game (1...e5) (against 1.e4) | 47.3% | 47.6% | 48.3% | 1,948,917 | 5,273,326 | 411,295 |
| Sicilian Defense (against 1.e4) | 50.5% | 49.3% | 47.8% | 294,818 | 3,158,607 | 687,633 |
| French Defense (against 1.e4) | 50.4% | 49.7% | 48.0% | 270,278 | 1,885,980 | 318,484 |
| Caro-Kann Defense (against 1.e4) | 50.4% | 49.6% | 47.6% | 257,958 | 1,635,111 | 303,193 |
| Scandinavian Defense (against 1.e4) | 48.5% | 49.7% | 48.4% | 444,357 | 1,967,994 | 226,276 |
| Queen's Gambit Declined (against 1.d4) | 46.9% | 46.8% | 46.8% | 30,426 | 317,258 | 65,234 |
| Slav Defense (against 1.d4) | 47.0% | 46.9% | 45.5% | 20,000 | 240,339 | 49,624 |
| King's Indian Defense (against 1.d4) | 50.4% | 49.5% | 47.7% | 9,046 | 166,865 | 66,096 |
| Dutch Defense (against 1.d4) | 48.1% | 48.1% | 47.7% | 18,369 | 172,073 | 30,192 |
| Defense | 1000 to 1199 | 1200 to 1399 | 1400 to 1599 | 1600 to 1999 | 2200 and up |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Open Game (1...e5)vs 1.e4 | 47.3%1,948,917 | 47.3%2,780,978 | 47.5%3,202,839 | 47.6%5,273,326 | 48.3%411,295 |
| Sicilian Defensevs 1.e4 | 50.5%294,818 | 50.2%594,616 | 50.0%1,012,211 | 49.3%3,158,607 | 47.8%687,633 |
| French Defensevs 1.e4 | 50.4%270,278 | 50.2%505,966 | 50.2%731,480 | 49.7%1,885,980 | 48.0%318,484 |
| Caro-Kann Defensevs 1.e4 | 50.4%257,958 | 50.3%463,845 | 50.5%656,224 | 49.6%1,635,111 | 47.6%303,193 |
| Scandinavian Defensevs 1.e4 | 48.5%444,357 | 49.1%646,794 | 49.8%873,254 | 49.7%1,967,994 | 48.4%226,276 |
| Queen's Gambit Declinedvs 1.d4 | 46.9%30,426 | 46.4%61,209 | 46.4%103,402 | 46.8%317,258 | 46.8%65,234 |
| Slav Defensevs 1.d4 | 47.0%20,000 | 47.1%40,484 | 47.5%68,106 | 46.9%240,339 | 45.5%49,624 |
| King's Indian Defensevs 1.d41.d4 Nf6 2.c4 g6 order; can overlap the Grünfeld row | 50.4%9,046 | 50.3%20,849 | 49.8%39,881 | 49.5%166,865 | 47.7%66,096 |
| Dutch Defensevs 1.d4 | 48.1%18,369 | 47.4%32,509 | 48.5%53,065 | 48.1%172,073 | 47.7%30,192 |
| Nimzo-Indian Defensevs 1.d4 | 48.0%1,732 | 47.5%4,851 | 47.7%11,523 | 48.7%59,564 | 48.4%32,038 |
| Grünfeld Defensevs 1.d4 | 47.5%*306 | 49.7%1,133 | 51.3%3,367 | 51.6%27,178 | 48.2%13,865 |
Score and games in each cell. * means fewer than 1,000 games. The King's Indian row counts every game that began 1.d4 Nf6 2.c4 g6, so it includes the games that went on to the Grünfeld row. 1200 to 1399 is the middle of the 800 to 1700 range this page is written for.
Black's score changes with rating, and not the same way for every defense. From 1000 to 1199 up to 2200 and up, Black's score with the Caro-Kann Defense falls from 50.4% to 47.6%, and with the Open Game (1...e5) it moves from 47.3% to 48.3%. At 2200 and up Black scores less than 50% with every defense on this page.
What players answer to 1.e4 and 1.d4
A defense is only useful if you meet the lines it leads to. These charts show how often each reply is played in the same three bands.
1...e5 is 53.4% of replies to 1.e4 at 1000 to 1199; the Sicilian rises from 8.1% to 28.4% at 2200 and up
Share of games that begin 1.e4, by Black's reply.
- 53.4% 1000 to 1199
- 32.2% 1600 to 1999
- 17.0% 2200 and up
- 8.1% 1000 to 1199
- 19.3% 1600 to 1999
- 28.4% 2200 and up
- 12.2% 1000 to 1199
- 12.0% 1600 to 1999
- 9.3% 2200 and up
- 7.4% 1000 to 1199
- 11.5% 1600 to 1999
- 13.1% 2200 and up
- 7.1% 1000 to 1199
- 10.0% 1600 to 1999
- 12.5% 2200 and up
- 3.7% 1000 to 1199
- 4.4% 1600 to 1999
- 6.0% 2200 and up
- 1.3% 1000 to 1199
- 1.8% 1600 to 1999
- 3.9% 2200 and up
- 6.8% 1000 to 1199
- 8.8% 1600 to 1999
- 9.9% 2200 and up
Show the numbers as a table
| Reply to 1.e4 | 1000 to 1199 | 1600 to 1999 | 2200 and up |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1...e5 (Open Game) | 53.4% | 32.2% | 17.0% |
| 1...c5 (Sicilian) | 8.1% | 19.3% | 28.4% |
| 1...d5 (Scandinavian) | 12.2% | 12.0% | 9.3% |
| 1...e6 (French) | 7.4% | 11.5% | 13.1% |
| 1...c6 (Caro-Kann) | 7.1% | 10.0% | 12.5% |
| 1...d6 | 3.7% | 4.4% | 6.0% |
| 1...Nf6 | 1.3% | 1.8% | 3.9% |
| All other replies | 6.8% | 8.8% | 9.9% |
1...d5 is 52.9% of replies to 1.d4 at 1000 to 1199 and 24.1% at 2200 and up; 1...Nf6 goes from 9.5% to 33.0%
Share of games that begin 1.d4, by Black's reply.
- 52.9% 1000 to 1199
- 39.8% 1600 to 1999
- 24.1% 2200 and up
- 9.5% 1000 to 1199
- 17.9% 1600 to 1999
- 33.0% 2200 and up
- 8.9% 1000 to 1199
- 10.3% 1600 to 1999
- 8.2% 2200 and up
- 3.8% 1000 to 1199
- 4.9% 1600 to 1999
- 5.4% 2200 and up
- 2.3% 1000 to 1199
- 4.7% 1600 to 1999
- 9.2% 2200 and up
- 1.4% 1000 to 1199
- 2.2% 1600 to 1999
- 1.9% 2200 and up
- 21.2% 1000 to 1199
- 20.1% 1600 to 1999
- 18.3% 2200 and up
Show the numbers as a table
| Reply to 1.d4 | 1000 to 1199 | 1600 to 1999 | 2200 and up |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1...d5 | 52.9% | 39.8% | 24.1% |
| 1...Nf6 (Indian setups) | 9.5% | 17.9% | 33.0% |
| 1...e6 | 8.9% | 10.3% | 8.2% |
| 1...c6 | 3.8% | 4.9% | 5.4% |
| 1...c5 | 2.3% | 4.7% | 9.2% |
| 1...f5 (Dutch) | 1.4% | 2.2% | 1.9% |
| All other replies | 21.2% | 20.1% | 18.3% |
Players at 1000 to 1199 answer 1.e4 with 1...e5 in more than half of games. The Sicilian grows with rating until it is the most played reply at 2200 and up. The tracked list does not cover every reply; the charts say how many games fall outside it.
What White plays against you
Most of Black's games begin with one of four first moves. 1.e4 and 1.d4 are the ones to prepare for first; 1.Nf3 and 1.c4 are covered in the section on rarer first moves below.
64.8% of games start 1.e4 at 1000 to 1199 and 43.4% at 2200 and up; 1.d4 is 23.0% and 29.0%
Share of games that start with each first move.
- 64.8% 1000 to 1199
- 58.8% 1600 to 1799
- 43.4% 2200 and up
- 23.0% 1000 to 1199
- 26.1% 1600 to 1799
- 29.0% 2200 and up
- 2.5% 1000 to 1199
- 2.8% 1600 to 1799
- 9.1% 2200 and up
- 1.6% 1000 to 1199
- 3.1% 1600 to 1799
- 5.0% 2200 and up
Show the numbers as a table
| First move | 1000 to 1199 | 1600 to 1799 | 2200 and up |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.e4 | 64.8% | 58.8% | 43.4% |
| 1.d4 | 23.0% | 26.1% | 29.0% |
| 1.Nf3 | 2.5% | 2.8% | 9.1% |
| 1.c4 | 1.6% | 3.1% | 5.0% |
One defense to 1.e4 and one to 1.d4 covers 87.8% of games at 1000 to 1199 and 72.4% at 2200 and up. The rarer first moves matter more as ratings rise: 1.Nf3 starts 2.5% of games at 1000 to 1199 and 9.1% at 2200 and up. The first-move shares were counted separately from the reply and score tables, so the middle band here is 1600 to 1799, where those tables use 1600 to 1999.
Aggressive defenses for Black
A game result cannot measure aggression, so start with the plans. Three to try if you want a sharp game as Black:
- Sicilian: ...c5 pressure on d4. Good if you want to trade a c-pawn for White's d-pawn and attack down the c-file.
- King's Indian: the ...f5 pawn break. Good if you will let White build a closed center and then attack the kingside.
- Dutch: ...f5 on move one. Good if you want kingside space and a fight for e4 from the start.
Draw frequency is a separate outcome from how sharp the play is. The chart shows how often each defense ends in a draw, so you can see how often a game ends with a winner.
Draws are 2.7% to 3.3% of games at 1000 to 1199 in every defense, and 5.2% to 10.5% at 2200 and up
Share of games that end in a draw, by defense, fewest draws at 2200 and up first.
- 3.2% 1000 to 1199
- 3.8% 1600 to 1999
- 5.2% 2200 and up
- 2.8% 1000 to 1199
- 3.8% 1600 to 1999
- 5.9% 2200 and up
- 2.9% 1000 to 1199
- 4.1% 1600 to 1999
- 6.4% 2200 and up
- 2.9% 1000 to 1199
- 3.9% 1600 to 1999
- 6.5% 2200 and up
- 2.7% 1000 to 1199
- 3.9% 1600 to 1999
- 7.0% 2200 and up
- 2.8% 1000 to 1199
- 4.2% 1600 to 1999
- 7.1% 2200 and up
- 3.0% 1000 to 1199
- 4.7% 1600 to 1999
- 7.4% 2200 and up
- 2.8% 1000 to 1199
- 4.5% 1600 to 1999
- 9.1% 2200 and up
- 3.3% 1000 to 1199
- 3.9% 1600 to 1999
- 10.5% 2200 and up
Show the numbers as a table
| Defense | 1000 to 1199 | 1600 to 1999 | 2200 and up | Games, 1000 to 1199 | Games, 1600 to 1999 | Games, 2200 and up |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scandinavian Defense (against 1.e4) | 3.2% | 3.8% | 5.2% | 444,357 | 1,967,994 | 226,276 |
| Dutch Defense (against 1.d4) | 2.8% | 3.8% | 5.9% | 18,369 | 172,073 | 30,192 |
| Caro-Kann Defense (against 1.e4) | 2.9% | 4.1% | 6.4% | 257,958 | 1,635,111 | 303,193 |
| French Defense (against 1.e4) | 2.9% | 3.9% | 6.5% | 270,278 | 1,885,980 | 318,484 |
| Sicilian Defense (against 1.e4) | 2.7% | 3.9% | 7.0% | 294,818 | 3,158,607 | 687,633 |
| King's Indian Defense (against 1.d4) | 2.8% | 4.2% | 7.1% | 9,046 | 166,865 | 66,096 |
| Slav Defense (against 1.d4) | 3.0% | 4.7% | 7.4% | 20,000 | 240,339 | 49,624 |
| Queen's Gambit Declined (against 1.d4) | 2.8% | 4.5% | 9.1% | 30,426 | 317,258 | 65,234 |
| Open Game (1...e5) (against 1.e4) | 3.3% | 3.9% | 10.5% | 1,948,917 | 5,273,326 | 411,295 |
At the ratings this page is written for, a draw is rare in every defense, so the choice depends on the position you want. The Scandinavian Defense has the fewest draws at 2200 and up (5.2%) and the Open Game (1...e5) the most (10.5%). Black scores 50.3% with the King's Indian line and 50.2% with the Sicilian at 1200 to 1399. The Sicilian Defense guide and the Scandinavian Defense guide have the lines to learn.
Chess openings for Black beginners
The Caro-Kann against 1.e4 and the Slav against 1.d4 make a starter pair. They share the ...c6 and ...d5 pawn structure, so some of what you learn in one carries to the other, but each has its own moves to learn. The Slav only arises when White plays 2.c4.
At 1000 to 1199 Black scores 50.4% with the Caro-Kann in 257,958 games and 47.0% with the Slav (1.d4 d5 2.c4 c6) in 20,000 games. Part of the gap is the first move, and the two samples differ in size. After 1.d4 d5, whatever White plays next, Black scores 46.6% in 685,767 games at 1000 to 1199; after 1.e4 c6 Black scores 50.4%. The Slav is a narrower sample than 1.d4 d5, so do not read its score as the score of 1.d4 d5.
If White plays 2.Bf4 instead of 2.c4, you can still play 2...c6 and keep the same pawns, then bring the light bishop out with ...Bf5. Our saved September 2026 stats for that position cover 1600 to 1999 only and do not include 2...c6. Of the four replies they do include, 2...c5 scores best for Black, 48.6% in 38,153 games, ahead of 2...Bf5 (47.4%), 2...Nf6 (47.2%), 2...e6 (46.7%).
The beginner page adds three White openings, the traps to avoid and the score of each opening at 1000 to 1399.
Chess openings for beginners: five to learn first · Caro-Kann Defense on a board
Black against 1.c4 and 1.Nf3
Other first moves are rarer but they come up: 1.Nf3 starts 2.4% of games at 1200 to 1399 and 1.c4 starts 2.0%.
1...e5 is 43.4% of replies to 1.c4 at 1000 to 1199, ahead of 1...Nf6 at 8.1%
Share of games that begin 1.c4, by Black's reply.
- 43.4% 1000 to 1199
- 26.7% 1600 to 1999
- 16.6% 2200 and up
- 8.1% 1000 to 1199
- 15.9% 1600 to 1999
- 21.6% 2200 and up
- 8.2% 1000 to 1199
- 11.5% 1600 to 1999
- 15.1% 2200 and up
- 8.3% 1000 to 1199
- 11.2% 1600 to 1999
- 12.0% 2200 and up
- 13.5% 1000 to 1199
- 10.5% 1600 to 1999
- 5.9% 2200 and up
- 4.5% 1000 to 1199
- 7.2% 1600 to 1999
- 10.0% 2200 and up
- 3.8% 1000 to 1199
- 6.3% 1600 to 1999
- 6.8% 2200 and up
- 10.3% 1000 to 1199
- 10.7% 1600 to 1999
- 12.0% 2200 and up
Show the numbers as a table
| Reply to 1.c4 | 1000 to 1199 | 1600 to 1999 | 2200 and up |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1...e5 | 43.4% | 26.7% | 16.6% |
| 1...Nf6 | 8.1% | 15.9% | 21.6% |
| 1...e6 | 8.2% | 11.5% | 15.1% |
| 1...c5 (Symmetrical) | 8.3% | 11.2% | 12.0% |
| 1...d5 | 13.5% | 10.5% | 5.9% |
| 1...c6 | 4.5% | 7.2% | 10.0% |
| 1...g6 | 3.8% | 6.3% | 6.8% |
| All other replies | 10.3% | 10.7% | 12.0% |
After 1.c4 e5 Black scores 46.9% at 1200 to 1399 in 72,155 games, and 46.5% after 1.c4 c5 in 16,023. After 1.Nf3, 1...d5 is 36.9% of replies and scores 47.5% for Black at 1200 to 1399; 1...Nf6 is 7.4% and scores 48.6%. The English Opening guide shows the main lines against 1.c4.
What strong players say about choosing the Sicilian
The Sicilian is the most played reply to 1.e4 at 2200 and up, with 687,633 games in September 2026. Two authors explain what Black gets for the extra homework.
"in many lines Black is playing not just for equality, but for the advantage"
John Nunn, Understanding Chess Move by Move (Gambit Publications, 2001), page 57. Quoted in Wikipedia, Sicilian Defence, read 17 November 2026.
That is the case for the Sicilian if you want winning chances as Black. Black scores 50.5% with it at 1000 to 1199 and 49.3% at 1600 to 1999. Nunn's next sentence names the price: White often obtains an early initiative, so Black has to take care not to fall victim to a quick attack.
"you have to give me one of your center pawns"
Jonathan Rowson, Chess for Zebras (Gambit Publications, 2005), page 243. Quoted in Wikipedia, Sicilian Defence, read 17 November 2026.
That is the trade at the heart of 1...c5: when White opens the center, Black has traded a wing pawn for a center pawn and gets the c-file. It is 8.1% of replies to 1.e4 at 1000 to 1199 and 28.4% at 2200 and up.
A model game for Black: Fischer against Byrne, 1956
Bobby Fischer, aged 13, beat Donald Byrne with the Black pieces in the Rosenwald Memorial Tournament at the Marshall Chess Club in New York on 17 October 1956, in 41 moves (Wikipedia, Game of the Century, read 17 November 2026). The game is listed as a Grünfeld Defense (ECO D92); the Grünfeld has its own row in the score table and entry under rarer defenses. The board shows Black at the bottom and opens at the queen sacrifice. Press "Replay from move one" to watch the whole game, step with the buttons, or tap a marked move to read its note.
After 17...Be6
17...Be6 is the queen sacrifice. The black queen on b6 stays attacked by the bishop on c5, and the bishop on e6 attacks White's bishop on c4.
Why 17...Be6 works
After 17...Be6 the black queen on b6 is still attacked. White takes it with 18.Bxb6, which leaves White ahead in material, 33 points to 25 (pawn 1, knight and bishop 3, rook 5, queen 9). But 18...Bxc4+ takes White's other bishop with check (30 to 25). Then the knight goes from c3 to e2 with check, and it also stands on the bishop's diagonal to f1. When White's king steps to f1, the knight leaves e2 and the bishop gives a discovered check (20...Nxd4+), and 21...Ne2+ and 22...Nc3+ repeat it. 23...axb6 takes the bishop on b6 once the checks stop, 26 to 25, and 25...Nxd1 takes a rook, which puts Black ahead, 24 to 21.
All the moves
1.Nf3 Nf6 2.c4 g6 3.Nc3 Bg7 4.d4 O-O 5.Bf4 d5 6.Qb3 dxc4 7.Qxc4 c6 8.e4 Nbd7 9.Rd1 Nb6 10.Qc5 Bg4 11.Bg5 Na4 12.Qa3 Nxc3 13.bxc3 Nxe4 14.Bxe7 Qb6 15.Bc4 Nxc3 16.Bc5 Rfe8+ 17.Kf1 Be6 18.Bxb6 Bxc4+ 19.Kg1 Ne2+ 20.Kf1 Nxd4+ 21.Kg1 Ne2+ 22.Kf1 Nc3+ 23.Kg1 axb6 24.Qb4 Ra4 25.Qxb6 Nxd1 26.h3 Rxa2 27.Kh2 Nxf2 28.Re1 Rxe1 29.Qd8+ Bf8 30.Nxe1 Bd5 31.Nf3 Ne4 32.Qb8 b5 33.h4 h5 34.Ne5 Kg7 35.Kg1 Bc5+ 36.Kf1 Ng3+ 37.Ke1 Bb4+ 38.Kd1 Bb3+ 39.Kc1 Ne2+ 40.Kb1 Nc3+ 41.Kc1 Rc2#
What to take from it as Black: Fischer let White put pawns on c4, d4 and e4, then struck at them with ...d5, ...c6 and ...Nxe4. Letting White build a center and then striking back is the Grünfeld idea (see its row in the score table) and also the plan on the King's Indian card.
Rarer defenses with fewer games
Two more defenses against 1.d4 have fewer than 10,000 games at 1200 to 1399, so they are listed here and not in the card grid.
Nimzo-Indian Defense
1.d4 Nf6 2.c4 e6 3.Nc3 Bb4 · you meet 1.d4
Pins the c3 knight with ...Bb4 to fight for the center.
Black scores 48.7% at 1600 to 1999 in 59,564 games and 48.4% at 2200 and up in 32,038. At 1200 to 1399 there are 4,851 games. Engine +0.18 for White after these moves (Stockfish 16, depth 16).
Grünfeld Defense
1.d4 Nf6 2.c4 g6 3.Nc3 d5 · you meet 1.d4
A fianchetto setup that hits White's center at once with ...d5.
Black scores 51.6% at 1600 to 1999 in 27,178 games and 48.2% at 2200 and up in 13,865. At 1200 to 1399 there are 1,133 games. Engine +0.32 for White after these moves (Stockfish 16, depth 16).
See every opening on its own board in all chess openings.
Questions players ask about openings for Black
What is the best opening for Black against 1.e4?
No reply is best for everyone, and the five main ones sit within 3.0 points of each other at 1200 to 1399 in our games. At 1000 to 1199 Black scores 50.5% with the Sicilian Defense, 50.4% with the French Defense and 50.4% with the Caro-Kann Defense, against 47.3% with 1...e5. Pick the one whose plans you will play every game: 594,616 games at 1200 to 1399 are Sicilians, 505,966 French and 463,845 Caro-Kann.
What is the best opening for Black against 1.d4?
Among the four 1.d4 defenses on this page, the King's Indian line scores best at 1200 to 1399: 50.3% for Black in 20,849 games, ahead of the Dutch at 47.4%, the Slav at 47.1% and the Queen's Gambit Declined at 46.4%. That King's Indian sample is every game that began 1.d4 Nf6 2.c4 g6, and 5.4% of those games went on to a Grünfeld with 3.Nc3 d5, so it is not a pure King's Indian count. The Slav and the Queen's Gambit Declined only arise after White plays 2.c4. Choose the King's Indian if you want to counterattack and will learn its plans; choose the Slav if you play the Caro-Kann against 1.e4 and want the same ...c6 and ...d5 pawns. Compare scores only inside one first move: Black starts from a different position after 1.d4 than after 1.e4.
What are the best chess openings for Black for beginners?
Start with one reply to each first move. The Caro-Kann against 1.e4 and the Slav against 1.d4 share the ...c6 and ...d5 pawn structure, though each has its own moves to learn. The Slav only arises after White plays 2.c4; against 2.Bf4 you keep the same pawns with 2...c6. At 1000 to 1199 Black scores 50.4% with the Caro-Kann in 257,958 games and 47.0% with the Slav in 20,000.
What are the most aggressive chess openings for Black?
Aggression shows up in plans more than in a statistic. Three to try: the Sicilian's ...c5 pressure on d4, the King's Indian's ...f5 pawn break against a closed center, and the Dutch's ...f5 from move one. Draw frequency is a separate outcome. At 1000 to 1199 only 2.7% of Sicilian games are drawn, and every defense on this page sits between 2.7% and 3.3%. At 2200 and up, among the Sicilian, King's Indian, Dutch and Scandinavian, the fewest draws are in the Scandinavian Defense (5.2%), then the Dutch Defense (5.9%).
Is the Caro-Kann the best opening for Black?
It is one of the best scoring replies to 1.e4 below 1600: Black scores 50.4% at 1000 to 1199, 50.3% at 1200 to 1399 and 50.5% at 1400 to 1599, within 0.5 points of the Sicilian and French in each band. At 2200 and up it scores 47.6%, the lowest of the five main replies. The Caro-Kann is a good fit if you want a sturdy structure with few early tricks; the gap to the Sicilian at 2200 and up is 0.2 points.
What is the Sicilian Defense?
The Sicilian Defense is Black's reply 1.e4 c5: Black fights for the d4 square from the side instead of copying White's pawn. It is the third most played reply to 1.e4 at 1000 to 1199 (294,818 games) and the most played at 2200 and up (687,633). John Nunn credits its lasting popularity to its combative nature (Understanding Chess Move by Move, Gambit Publications, 2001, page 57, quoted in Wikipedia's Sicilian Defence article, read 17 November 2026).
What is better, Black or White in chess?
White has a small edge from moving first. White scores 51.8% at 1000 to 1199 and 52.3% at 2200 and up, which is 1.8 and 2.3 points above 50%; Black scores 48.2% and 47.7% (wins plus half the draws, 5,628,817 and 5,590,869 Lichess games from September 2026).
What did Bobby Fischer play against 1.e4?
The Sicilian. Wikipedia's Sicilian Defence article says Fischer and Kasparov "employed the Sicilian almost exclusively throughout their careers" (read 17 November 2026). The model game above shows him in a Grünfeld Defense in 1956, which began 1.Nf3 and reached the Grünfeld by transposition. In our games Black scores 49.3% with the Sicilian at 1600 to 1999.
What opening is 1.e4 e5 2.Nc3 Nf6 3.f4?
It is the Vienna Gambit, a line of the Vienna Game (opening names: lichess-org/chess-openings, CC0, saved in our openings data). It starts from 1.e4 e5, the reply in 53.4% of games that begin 1.e4 at 1000 to 1199.
How should Black play against 1.c4 and 1.Nf3?
They are rarer: 1.c4 is 2.0% of first moves at 1200 to 1399 and 1.Nf3 is 2.4%. Against 1.c4 the most common replies at 1200 to 1399 are 1...e5 (40.0%), 1...d5 (12.4%), 1...Nf6 (9.4%). Against 1.Nf3, 1...d5 is 36.9% of replies and 1...Nf6 is 7.4%.
Can I play the same defense against 1.e4 and 1.d4?
Partly. 1...d5 is a reply to both: the Scandinavian against 1.e4, and the Slav or Queen's Gambit Declined against 1.d4 once White plays 2.c4. The Caro-Kann and the Slav share the ...c6 and ...d5 pawn structure. If White skips 2.c4, there is no Slav: after 1.d4 d5 2.Bf4 you keep the same pawns with 2...c6.
Is the Scandinavian Defense good for Black?
It scores below the Sicilian, French and Caro-Kann at the lowest rating bands and catches up as ratings rise: Black scores 48.5% at 1000 to 1199, 49.8% at 1400 to 1599 and 49.7% at 1600 to 1999 (1,967,994 games). Against that, 5.2% of its games at 2200 and up are drawn, the fewest of the nine defenses here.
